Coleman WeatherMaster Tent (6-Person): Definitive Review (2020)

Spacious Luxury and Nifty Features -
A Roomy Tent Fit For Large Groups...

Subscribe to our
monthly FREE STUFF give aways

Table of Contents

31

Models Reviewed

23

Hours Of
Research

26

Field Test
Hours

65

Users
Surveyed

TopNotch Outdoor is independent – we research, test, and rate the top products to help you make the right buying choice. We sometimes use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on your purchase. Learn more…

This is the Ultimate TopNotch Review of the Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent 2020

A detailed guide of a tent that provides incredible comfort.

We’ve tested it alongside nine other 6-person structures in all types of outdoor environments.

If you want to see how we rated this tent… just keep reading.

In this comprehensive review we’ll cover:

  • Unique features and general specifications
  • Weather resistance and overall durability
  • Set-up process and ease of use
  • Lots more…

So if you want the lowdown of exactly where this tent shines and where it comes up short…  you’ll love this guide.

Let’s get started.

Value for Money
7
Ease of Use
8
Durability/Workmanship
6
Comfort
9
Weather Resistance
6
Overall Score
72

  • Weight: 32 lbs
  • Square Footage: 99 square feet living space
  • Height: 6’10”
  • Seasons: 3 Seasons
  • Manufacturer: Coleman

Bottom Line : An excellent tent for all weather, especially at this price point

Pros


  • Superior quality
  • Massive interior
  • 2 rooms
  • Hinged door

Cons


  • Requires thorough waterproofing before use
  • Heavy

Our Verdict:
Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent

The WeatherMaster Tent provided a roomy feel even with 6 people stuffed inside.

Its additional screen room was an awesome feature we didn’t see in many of the other tents we tested.

On top of this, it came loaded with Coleman seams which are always inverted and taped to seal out unwanted dirt, rain, or mud.

But…

…the tent did have a few hangups.

Mostly due to its slightly difficult set-up process, and overall weather resistance. Unfortunately, it also has a slightly larger weight at about 32 pounds.

If you’re looking for a comfortable and restful stay at the campground, then this tent could be perfect for your future outdoor trips.

Specially-angled windows keep rain out when the windows are open.”

Related: 10 Best 6 Person Tents

Analysis Comparisons and Test Results

We put ten 6-person tents under the microscope and analyzed how they fared in all sorts of situations.

So, you can be sure that if a tent did well in rain but poorly in intense sunlight, we figured it all out.

We used various metrics to help us compare these structures side by side, and you’ll find how the Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent did in a second.

From our experience… this tent could be just right for those not willing to give up on comfort just because they have a large party sleeping in their cabin.

Value for Money

Although we think the Eureka Copper Canyon 6 is the best value 6-person tent out there for your money…

If the Weathermaster’s additional room or incredibly cozy feel intrigues you…

…join the club – we were the same.

Coleman WeatherMaster Tent

Value for Money Rating

Eureka Copper Canyon 6
9
CORE 6-Person Instant Cabin Tent
9
The North Face Wawona 6
8
Big Agnes 6-Person Tent
8
Coleman Sundome 6
8
Coleman Weathermaster 6-Person Tent with Screen Room
7
CORE 6-Person Dome Tent
7
Marmot Halo 6
6
Nemo Wagontop 6
6
Kodiak Canvas Tent
6

This tent may be a tad pricier than some of the other models we tested, but it’s by no means the most expensive.

We do wish it was a bit more weather resistant, however, as it takes a fair bit of effort to fully weather-proof this tent yourself.

Its quality Coleman craftsmanship speaks for itself, as it comes fully fitted with taped seams, and an easy to use hinged-door.

Bottom Line?

This tent will be worth every dime you spend on it thanks to its amazing mix of comfort and spaciousness.

Ease of Use & Set-Up

Even with its extra screen room, this tent finished in the top 5 of its class for ease of use and set-up.

Being intimidated by the large number of poles, rods, and stakes necessary for the set-up process is normal, but we promise you need not be afraid of this tent.

.

Coleman WeatherMaster Tent

Ease of Use & Set-Up Rating

CORE 6-Person Instant Cabin Tent
9
The North Face Wawona 6
9
Eureka Copper Canyon 6
9
Coleman Weathermaster 6-Person Tent with Screen Room
8
Coleman Sundome 6
8
Marmot Halo 6
8
CORE 6-Person Dome Tent
7
Big Agnes 6-Person Tent
7
Nemo Wagontop 6
6
Kodiak Canvas Tent
6

You can raise this tent in under 20 minutes, which is hard to believe when you see its huge size or feel its unique roominess.

Like any tent, however, we did find a few problems with its ease of use.

First, it does come with a somewhat hefty overall weight at 32 pounds.

It also comes with a plethora of poles which can be annoying and confusing to figure out the first few times you put it up. Specifically, there are 4 large straight poles, 4 shorter straight poles, 4 curved ridge poles, 2 door poles, and 2 awning poles.

Here is a great time lapse video of the set-up process.

But… as I mentioned before, these issues are us being a bit nitpicky.

With an overall score of 8/10 for ease of use and set-up, it’s amazing how this tent (quite literally) pops up at the campsite.

Durability & Workmanship

Nobody wants a tent that won’t last for multiple seasons because of poor craftsmanship.

If durability is one of your highest priorities then we’d recommend a tent such as the North Face Wawona 6 or the Eureka Copper Canyon 6 which scored exceptionally well in this category.

Coleman WeatherMaster Tent (6-Person)

Durability & Workmanship Rating

The North Face Wawona 6
9
Eureka Copper Canyon 6
8
Kodiak Canvas Tent
8
CORE 6-Person Instant Cabin Tent
8
Marmot Halo 6
7
Coleman Sundome 6
7
CORE 6-Person Dome Tent
7
Big Agnes 6-Person Tent
7
Nemo Wagontop 6
7
Coleman Weathermaster 6-Person Tent with Screen Room
6

Unfortunately, the Weathermaster had some issues regarding its workmanship and potential longevity.

We found the Coleman stakes that came with the tent to be a little weak, and difficult to drive into the ground.

Also… the rain fly didn’t fully cover the tent screen (especially over the screen room), which could lead to weather-related wear and tear which will stack up over the years.

That being said… Coleman does make reliable tents, and they used their patented welded floors on this product.

Furthermore, it’s made from a durable poly guard fabric we loved.

Comfort

When camping comfort is king…the Coleman WeatherMaster takes the crown.

We really can’t say enough about the luxury this tent offers. For classic car camping scenarios, there may not be a better choice out there.

Coleman WeatherMaster Tent (6-Person)

Comfort Rating

Coleman Weathermaster 6-Person Tent with Screen Room
9
The North Face Wawona 6
9
CORE 6-Person Instant Cabin Tent
9
Eureka Copper Canyon 6
8
CORE 6-Person Dome Tent
8
Big Agnes 6-Person Tent
8
Marmot Halo 6
7
Nemo Wagontop 6
7
Coleman Sundome 6
7
Kodiak Canvas Tent
7

It easily fits two queen-sized beds, and its lofted ceilings are high enough so that most people can stand inside without needing to crouch.

Like most tents with screen room additions, the comfort level is enhanced by the option to enjoy a sunset, without so much of a thought about bugs.

Also, a tent with a screen house like this one is great for storing muddy or dirty gear after a long day outdoors.

Overall, the comfort factor of the Weathermaster is TopNotch.

Weather Resistance

Although it had enough room to fit an army, the Weathermaster struggled to keep that army fully dry.

If weather resistance is a make or break factor for you when buying an outdoor product, then maybe try the Kodiak Canvas Flex-Bow Tent rather than this.

Coleman WeatherMaster Tent

Weather Resistance Rating

Kodiak Canvas Tent
9
Nemo Wagontop 6
9
The NorthFace Wawona 6
8
Marmot Halo 6
8
CORE 6-Person Instant Cabin Tent
8
Eureka Copper Canyon 6
7
Big Agnes 6-Person Tent
7
CORE 6-Person Dome Tent
7
Coleman Sundome 6
7
Coleman Weathermaster 6-Person Tent with Screen Room
6

Furthermore, its plethora of windows and doors can make inclement weather a little more tricky.

Coleman products often feature bathtub style floors and inverted seams, (meaning the seam between floor and tent is off the ground for better protection, and the holes of the seams are within the tent).

These floors and inverted seams make for a worthy opponent to dirt, rain, or anything else trying to get inside your tent’s cabin walls.

“Rainfly offers added weather protection and mesh roof allows for more sunlight.”

Our Final Verdict:
Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent

The Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent could make your next outdoor adventure so much more pleasant, comfortable, and enjoyable.

It comes with an additional porch which is useful and just plain cool.

If the issues regarding weather resistance and general durability are too big for you to overlook, then we would quickly recommend the CORE 6-Person Instant Cabin.

But… there is nothing better than hopping in a roomy, spacious tent like this after a night of campfire stories, smores, and cold beers.

Our Final Verdict Rating

CORE 6-Person Instant Cabin Tent - EDITORS CHOICE
86%
The North Face Wawona 6
86%
Eureka Copper Canyon 6 - BEST VALUE
82%
Coleman Sundome 6
74%
Big Agnes 6-Person Tent
74%
CORE 6-Person Dome Tent
74%
Coleman Weathermaster 6-Person Tent with Screen Room
72%
Marmot Halo 6
72%
Kodiak Canvas Tent
72%
Nemo Wagontop 6
68%
Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent Review✓ 26 Hrs Field Testing✓ Pros & Cons✓ 3 Season✓ Great Value✓ WeatherTec System✓ Screen Room✓ Massive Interior✓

Conclusion: Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent

Let’s go over the main points from this review…

This Coleman WeatherMaster 6-Person Tent was our highest scorer in terms of overall comfort. Mostly due to its roomy cabin space and spacious porch addition.

Furthermore, despite its large size… the tent was surprisingly easy to set-up

So, to supercharge your campsite comfort, look no further than this Weathermaster from Coleman.

We’ve done the hard work – now we pass the baton to you to make your choice – which will it be?

Other Versions: Coleman WeatherMaster Tent

A similar product made by Coleman is their Dome Tent. It’s made from different materials but it comes with a similar porch addition and is an interesting and less expensive option.

topnotchoutdoor award

The REI Kingdom 6
topnotchoutdoor award

Coleman Weathermaster 10
topnotchoutdoor award

Big Agnes Flying Diamond 6