The Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's is our warmest fabric here pick, and we rate it 62 out of 100.
A 425g Alpenex II cardigan whose tight weave holds heat like a softshell, with no elastane anywhere in it.
Scored on Comfort, Warmth, Breathability, Layering and Weight, then revised downward once owner reports on durability came in.
Warmest Fabric Here
Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's
- Weight: 425g
- Fabric: Alpenex II, 100% recycled polyester, no elastane
- Weight class: Midweight
- Pockets: 2 hand, 1 arm
- Hood: No
- Durability flag: Early pilling reported at sleeve and waist contact points
Pros
- Warmest fabric in the whole test
- Behaves like a softshell in wind
- Genuinely high build quality
Cons
- Pills badly at contact points within weeks
- Stiff, abrasive collar against the neck
- No elastane, so it restricts arm movement
- Heavy and slow to dry
Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's: Our Call
The warmest fabric in the test wrapped around a jacket that pills early and does nothing else well.
We ended up scoring it 62 out of 100, our warmest fabric here of the group.
Warmest fabric in the whole test is the reason it beat the rest.
The flip side: pills badly at contact points within weeks.
If you are shopping as short cold outings close to home where nothing rubs against the fabric, start here.
Warmest thing here by a distance, and the collar scratched at my chin every time I zipped it up. Then the owner reports came in about pilling at the waist within weeks, and that settled it for me.
Emma, Top-Notch test team
Test Results and Where It Ranks
Best score: warmth. Worst: layering.
Where it gained ground and where it lost it:
Comfort
6 out of 10 in our testing, and we now think that was generous. Alpenex II has no elastane, so it is rigid and it limits arm movement in a way the Kyanite does not.
The tall unlined collar is stiff and abrasive against the neck and chin, which is the concrete version of what our testers logged as an off fit. The current cut divided the team and nobody warmed to it.
| Comfort | Rating |
|---|---|
| Highest in this guide | 9/10 |
| Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's | 6/10 |
| Guide average | 7.1/10 |
| Lowest in this guide | 5/10 |
Warmth
9 out of 10, the highest score anywhere in this test.
The tight weave holds body heat and stops wind stripping it away, so it behaves more like a softshell than a fleece.
That single number is carrying the jacket's entire ranking.
| Warmth | Rating |
|---|---|
| Highest in this guide | 9/10 |
| Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's | 9/10 |
| Guide average | 7.1/10 |
| Lowest in this guide | 5/10 |
Breathability
5 out of 10, and the same tight weave is the reason.
It is a standing-around jacket, and it is genuinely good at being one.
| Breathability | Rating |
|---|---|
| Highest in this guide | 8.5/10 |
| Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's | 5/10 |
| Guide average | 6.4/10 |
| Lowest in this guide | 3/10 |
Layering
5 out of 10.
Bulky, and awkward to get anything over.
| Layering | Rating |
|---|---|
| Highest in this guide | 8.5/10 |
| Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's | 5/10 |
| Guide average | 6.4/10 |
| Lowest in this guide | 5/10 |
Weight
425g, one of the heavier jackets here, with long drying times to match.
We dropped its overall score after owner reports of face-fabric pilling on the inner sleeves and waist within weeks of purchase.
That is the loudest durability complaint of any jacket in this group, and a months-long test simply cannot see it.
| Weight | Rating |
|---|---|
| Highest in this guide | 9.5/10 |
| Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's | 7.1/10 |
| Guide average | 7.9/10 |
| Lowest in this guide | 4.5/10 |
The Case For and Against It
It is best suited to short cold outings close to home where nothing rubs against the fabric.
What you are paying for: Warmest fabric in the whole test.
What you give up: Pills badly at contact points within weeks.
If Not This One, Then What?
Different priorities? Start with one of these.
The North Face Retro Denali Women's, our warmest for standing still. The only true heavyweight here, and far more technical than the heritage styling suggests.
Arc'teryx Kyanite Hoody Women's, our best overall. It feels like a worn-in sweatshirt and performs like technical kit, which is a combination nothing else here manages.
Columbia Benton Springs Full Zip Women's, our best budget buy. The warmest jacket you can buy at the budget end, as long as the proportions suit you.
Specifications
| Weight | 425g |
| Fabric | Alpenex II, 100% recycled polyester, no elastane |
| Weight class | Midweight |
| Pockets | 2 hand, 1 arm |
| Hood | No |
| Durability flag | Early pilling reported at sleeve and waist contact points |
Our Take
Put against nine rivals, the Arc'teryx Covert Cardigan Women's earned our warmest fabric here award on 62 out of 100.
Warmest fabric in the whole test, and nothing else here matches it.
The one caveat is pills badly at contact points within weeks.
Right buyer: short cold outings close to home where nothing rubs against the fabric.
The rest of the lineup, ranked, is in our 9 Best Women's Fleece Jackets, Tested and Ranked guide.
