The Best Wellington Boots: Definitive Guide 2020

Work or Fun, We’ve Chosen the Best Wellingtons to Keep Your Feet Protected

Men's Carhartt Wellington Boots
topnotchoutdoor award

Jileon Rain Boots
topnotchoutdoor award

Danner Men's Boots (Crafter)

Models Reviewed

Hours Of
Research

Field Test
Hours

Users
Surveyed

TopNotch Outdoor is independent – we research, test, and rate the top products to help you make the right buying choice. We sometimes use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on your purchase. Learn more…

We took the 10 Best Wellington Boots and field-tested them to destruction to bring you this Ultimate TopNotch review of the top ten Wellington boots of 2020.

As usual, we’ve added a comprehensive buyer’s guide to help you make the best choice.

In this guide, we’ll discuss the following:

  • The three all-time best Wellington boots to choose
  • A side by side comparison of the best models
  • Expert tips for buying
  • Lots more…

Want to pick the best Wellies that will not only keep your feet warm in wet weather but also look super-stylish?

We have everything right here…

Let’s get started.

If you’re the outdoorsy type, you’re probably looking for footwear that can handle adverse weather and terrain conditions.

For sure, you need to stay warm and dry, but – what about the style factor?

Wellington boots are made from a variety of materials.

So style and utility can go hand in hand if you do your research.

The simple truth is – from parties and festivals – to camping –  Wellingtons are the jack of all trades.

The excellent all-round protection they offer is one factor behind their popularity.

As usual

… we field-tested for this review in our typical TopNotch style – the rigorous way.

We started by looking at the top 22 models on the market today, and after reading reviews and checking out the specs, we honed them down to the very best 10.

First stage complete.

We then used them thoroughly in a variety of outdoor conditions. We took them through a series of tests to judge the overall performance.

While they are all excellent products in their own way, we tested them in detail to determine how they perform in the worst conditions and see how durable they were when put through their paces.

Honestly, we had a hard time selecting the top three products from the results. They were all outstanding.

So at the end of the day – what did we decide?

Keep reading, and we’ll let you in on all the results and our final verdict.

Best Wellington Boots For Walking

1 – Men’s Carhartt Wellington Boots

Editors Choice Award Winner
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B075R5RK1J&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B075R5RK1J

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
8
Comfort
9
Durability/Workmanship
8
Waterproof
8
Overall Score
66
  • Manufacturer: Carhartt
  • Type: Work Boot
  • Weight: 1.94 pounds
  • Colour: Peanut Oil Tan Leather
  • Height of Upper: 11 inches
  • Size: 8 to 15

Bottom Line : Excellent work boots with the perfect style quotient

Pros


  • Stylish design
  • Reduces foot fatigue
  • Top-class breathability
  • Chemical and abrasion-resistant
  • Safe against electrical hazards

Cons


  • It’s pricey
  • Durability is not the best

In a nutshell, this is an industrial boot with a superb level of comfort.

That’s what makes the Carhartt Men’s Ground Force Wellington Boot a trendy choice.

The outer surface is oil-tanned leather combined with a waterproof breathable membrane. Also, there are plenty of advanced features, including Insite® technology for the footbed.

The composite toe and the rubber heel means you get full protection. The specially designed Ground Force rubber outsole delivered excellent traction.

Remarkably, even with all these features, Carhartt has managed to keep them lightweight enough that they were comfortable all day.

Also, the outer membrane was breathable enough to keep our feet dry and fresh for extended periods.

We loved the fact that we could wear them comfortably straight from the box (no break-in period), and the fit was perfect for the sizing.

Honestly, the excellent comfort levels meant you could sleep in these boots and not notice them.

Also…

… they also meet the ASTM 2413-18 EH safety standards against chemicals and electrical circuits.

In other words, complete protection for your feet.

The only hitch I noted was a bit of stitching that rubbed against the lower end of my calf. Make sure you wear thick socks with this pair of Wellington.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Your Money

2 – Jileon Rain Boots

Best Value Award Winner
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00IPNII3A&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B00IPNII3A

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
9
Comfort
9
Durability/Workmanship
7
Waterproof
9
Overall Score
64
  • Manufacturer: Jileon
  • Type: Rainboot
  • Weight: 3.95 pounds
  • Colour: Multiple
  • Height of Upper: 9 to 11 inches
  • Size: 6 to 11

Bottom Line : A stylish and practical rain boot for extra-wide calves

Pros


  • Top-class waterproofing
  • Reliable traction
  • Available in multiple colors
  • Extra-wide calves

Cons


  • The ankle area can be too large for some
  • Niggling issues with durability

You’ve tried everything.

But you can’t seem to get adequate rain boots that offer the right fit.

It’s time to try the Jileon women’s rain boots. They’re specially designed to fit extra-wide calves and offer the best levels of comfort.

The secret is

… a unique double gusset design that can fit calf sizes ranging between 16 to 23 inches.

At the same time, the wide-fit mold gave our tester an ankle area spacious enough to give her top levels of comfort.

The result was a comfy pair of rubber boots that could soak up wet conditions easily.

Do they slip?

Not at all.

We checked the performance of the non-slip soles on wet surfaces and never missed a step.

The padded insoles also delivered superb comfort over many hours.

However, while these boots are perfect for puddles, they aren’t designed for cold weather.

You’ll already know that finding the right fit can be somewhat challenging if you have narrow feet with wide calves.

Lastly, they’re available in multiple colors.

If you’re looking for a real value for money product with TopNotch performance, it’s your lucky day.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Work

3 – Danner Men’s Boots (Crafter)

Top Pick Award Winner
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B01MY2WAHB&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B01MY2WAHB

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
8
Comfort
8
Durability/Workmanship
7
Waterproof
9
Overall Score
64
  • Manufacturer: Danner
  • Type: Work Boot
  • Weight: 59 oz
  • Colour: Brown
  • Height of Upper: 11 inches
  • Size: 8 to 14

Bottom Line : Danner has packed some excellent features in this reliable pair of boots

Pros


  • Top-grade nubuck leather
  • Light and stylish design
  • The outsole offers excellent traction
  • EH certified protection
  • Dual-density footbed

Cons


  • The fit may be too tight for some
  • They are non-insulated

Want a boot that’ll keep your feet cool – even after hours of use?

Well, you can’t go wrong with the Danner Men’s Crafter Wellington NMT Work Boot.

The combination of nubuck leather and the Danner Dry waterproof protection meant total waterproofing in our tests.

What we loved was the extra-plush DCS footbed that gave good cushioning.

At the same time, the airflow through the foot chamber was good, and there’s also the Airthotic® heel clip for additional support.

On top of that

…if you’re using them in a work environment – there’s electrical hazard (EH) protection and oil and slip-resistant soles.

The fit is true-to-size, and the extra-wide toe box means they’re even more comfortable.

But…

… the fit might just be a little too snug for those with large feet – perfect for average feet, though.

Danner claims you can wear this boot right out of the box.

However

…. Our experience was different – we needed a few days break-in for them to relax.

Danner could have added some toe protection to go that extra mile on the safety front.

Read Full Review:

Go to Analysis, Comparisons & Ratings

Best Wellington Boots For Farming

4 – Guide Gear Men’s Mid Bogger Waterproof Rubber Boots

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B01EAMZ6FW&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B01EAMZ6FW

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
8
Comfort
6
Durability/Workmanship
7
Waterproof
8
Overall Score
58
  • Manufacturer: Guide Gear
  • Type: Waterproof Boots
  • Weight: 29 oz
  • Colour: Black
  • Height of Upper: 16 inches
  • Size: 8 to 14

Bottom Line : With superb waterproofing and an affordable price tag, this is a good choice for those on a tight budget

Pros


  • Neoprene rubber construction
  • Full waterproofing
  • Extremely lightweight
  • Great value

Cons


  • The fit is narrow
  • Cushioning could have been better
  • Durability isn’t the best

The truth is, we all love value for money products.

And the Guide Gear men’s mid bogger waterproof rubber boots give 100% waterproofing at an almost unbelievable price.

At a first glance, you might not be impressed.

But trust me, give them a go – they are fully waterproof.

There are the 5mm neoprene top and a calendar rubber outsole, which gave excellent traction.

They feel right at home on your feet over wet and muddy surfaces.

The removable insole gave us decent cushioning.

But if you want your Wellies plush or luxury, you do need to look elsewhere.

Beyond that, there’s the loop that makes pulling on and taking off easier.

You can’t expect insulation at this price point. So keep them in the cupboard in winter.

Also, the fit runs narrow, so make sure you’re generous when choosing the size.

On the whole, these boots took me through mud and muck without a hitch.

The performance in wet conditions was second only to our Best Value Award Winner.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Fishing

5 – Georgia Boots For Men (Homeland Wellington)

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00G1DPADW&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B00G1DPADW

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
6
Comfort
7
Durability/Workmanship
4
Waterproof
8
Overall Score
50
  • Manufacturer: Georgia
  • Type: Work Boots
  • Weight: 3 pounds
  • Colour: Brown
  • Height of Upper: 11 inches
  • Size: 8 to 13

Bottom Line : Georgia delivers good waterproofing through quality materials in this boot

Pros


  • Top class full-grain leather
  • Excellent waterproofing
  • Good quality EVA midsole
  • Oil-resistant outsole

Cons


  • Lack of attention to details
  • No all-round protection
  • Durability is not the best

If you’re looking for something stylish, the Georgia Boot men’s Homeland Wellington work shoe is a must-see.

With full-grain waterproof leather and 900d cordura® fabric, the boot is fully waterproof.

With a high rise, it is a good choice for tackling rough weather.

However, the calf circumference might not be big enough for everyone.

What else?

There was a steel shank for added arch support.

But that did increase the weight a bit.

The polyurethane TDC insole cushions are super comfortable and also help the airflow. That kept my feet dry.

But that’s not all.

The draw-pulls at the top aren’t padded. They did get pretty uncomfortable against my calves; I had them on for extended periods.

Then again – take note – there are no extra safety features like electrical hazard protection.

From the feedback of long-term users, the soles can tend to come off after a few months.

To sum up, a pair of Wellies that feel good but lacked in the reliability department.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Shooting

6 – Dunlop Boots For Men/ Women (Winter Wellington)

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B004TF7PQ4&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B004TF7PQ4

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
8
Comfort
7
Durability/Workmanship
7
Waterproof
8
Overall Score
60
  • Manufacturer: Dunlop
  • Type: Rain Boots
  • Weight: 4.94 pounds
  • Colour: Green
  • Height of Upper: 14-inches
  • Size: 10

Bottom Line : A traditionally styled Wellie you can rely on for heavy-duty outdoor use

Pros


  • Great for outdoor use
  • 100% waterproof
  • Offers great value
  • Excellent traction

Cons


  • No ankle support
  • Cushioning is not the best
  • No safety features

If you like the classic Wellington boot’s classic design, then this product from Dunlop is a perfect choice for you.

News flash: These are one of the cheapest Wellies we found online.

They’re full height waterproof boots made from a combination of PVC and rubber.

The exact composition is a business secret.

Very cloak and dagger!

While they’re not as comfortable as some, they’re pretty durable for rough use.

Also, I’ve added mine to my kit in the trunk – for emergency use.

We were super impressed by the design of the aggressive grooves on the sole.

Such a good grip on wet surfaces.

At this price, we weren’t expecting any ankle support, and we were right.

Still, these wellies were comfortable for trudging through rough patches in our tests.

Also

… there’s a decent amount of insulation for light winters.

If you want something stylish, you should probably look elsewhere. But these are trusty workhorses great for fieldwork or gardening.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Men

 7 – Georgia Boot Men’s (Carbo Tec-M Georgia)

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B01ALRJRAK&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B01ALRJRAK

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
6
Comfort
8
Durability/Workmanship
8
Waterproof
8
Overall Score
60
  • Manufacturer: Georgia
  • Type: Work Boot
  • Weight: 3 pounds
  • Colour: Brown
  • Height of Upper: 11 inches
  • Size: 7 to 14

Bottom Line : A Wellie that gets most things right and provides an adequate level of support and protection

Pros


  • Great quality of leather
  • Durable Goodyear welt construction
  • Stylish mid-calf design
  • Completely waterproof

Cons


  • A narrow fit
  • The sizing is not accurate
  • Lacks all-round protection

Here is something special…

This Wellie is made from SPR leather. A superior quality of leather that’s three times tougher and 2 1/2 times more resistant towards abrasions.

Moreover, it also provides better protection against all types of barnyard chemicals. That makes this boot an excellent pick for working in farms and ranches.

Due to the lack of protection from other hazards, we couldn’t count it as a feature-rich work boot.

Next, there is a Comfort Core® insole that offers a superior level of support and cushioning. The Carbo-Tec outsole is specially designed and is oil and slip-resistant.

To top it off, Georgia has added a fiberglass shank for arch support. That does make the boot lighter than those with a steel shank.

Now, the boot does take some time to break-in. Also, we found the area around the toe box slightly narrow. So those with wide feet may not like the fit.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Women

 8 – Polar Women’s Winter Rain Boots

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00MDKVKFE&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B00MDKVKFE

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
8
Comfort
6
Durability/Workmanship
6
Waterproof
8
Overall Score
56
  • Manufacturer: Polar
  • Type: Winter and rain boot
  • Weight: 3.46 pounds
  • Colour: Black
  • Height of Upper: 15.5 inches
  • Size: 5 to 12

Bottom Line : An easy to use Wellington boot for women, both for the rain and cold winters

Pros


  • High-quality natural rubber body
  • Quick-Dry textile lining
  • Slip-resistant outsole
  • Affordable price

Cons


  • Support levels not good
  • It is not very durable

Now, Polar is a brand that you’ve perhaps not heard of.

But they have a wide range of Wellies – outdoor products – available in their collection.

These Wellington boots from Polar are designed for use in winter.

This Wellie won’t turn heads with its looks.

But make up for it with some useful functionality.

Does it have a solid insulating layer?

Not really.

It’s the natural vulcanized rubber that makes them resistant to cold.

Also…

… there was a textile lining making them warmer and more comfortable for our tester.

We tested them on some tricky surfaces and said the rubber soles were happily slip-resistant.

While their support could have been better, the waterproof-ness was reliable in the wet.

In addition, you can adjust the calf—a practical feature.

But looking at feedback from long term users, we couldn’t mark them as exceptionally durable.

The use of vulcanized rubber also gives them that extra weight- not something we appreciate.

Overall, it’s a decent winter boot for women – with an attractive price tag.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Toddlers

 9 – Hatley Boys’ Printed Rain Boots

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07FKNQ5RH&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B07FKNQ5RH

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
8
Comfort
8
Durability/Workmanship
8
Waterproof
7
Overall Score
62
  • Manufacturer: Hatley
  • Type: Kid’s rain boots
  • Weight: 10 ounces
  • Colour: Multiple
  • Height of Upper: 7 inches approximately
  • Size: Kids and child

Bottom Line : The vivid Wellingtons are perfect for your kids to play in the puddles

Pros


  • Colorful designs
  • 100% rubber construction
  • Cotton lining
  • Good quality soles

Cons


  • The sizing can be confusing
  • Comfort levels are not the best

When it comes to kids, you need something bright and exciting. You need them to ‘want’ to wear them when needed.

Right?

The Hatley Boys’ Printed rain boots are available in a wide range of colors and designs that kids will love.

My toddler wouldn’t take his off; only exchanged them for his superman slippers after a skirmish.

The 100% rubber construction makes them useful for rainy days.

There’s also a cotton fabric lining for extra comfort.

The good thing is, they fitted true to size and hardly need any break-in time at all.

However

… some long term users did report that they had problems with sizing.

Make sure you check the size guide for toddlers, small kids, and large kids.

But there’s more…

You get a pull-on closure that makes them super easy to put on and take off.

Also, it’s easy to clean the removable insole after a day in the garden – just bung it in the wash.

News Flash: These were also our Editor’s Choice for the best Wellies for kids. Considering the reasonable price and the TopNotch features, these are some of the best Wellies available for your kids.

Read Full Review:

Best Wellington Boots For Dog Walking

 10 – HUNTER Women’s Original Short Rain Boot

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00K1WB8R6&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=topnotch096 20ir?t=topnotch096 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B00K1WB8R6

Check Latest Price
Value for Money
7
Comfort
7
Durability/Workmanship
8
Waterproof
8
Overall Score
60
  • Manufacturer: Hunter
  • Type: Rain Boot
  • Weight: 1.69 pounds
  • Colour: Multiple
  • Height of Upper: 12.125 inches
  • Size: 5 to 11

Bottom Line : A stylish pair of Wellies for women – great for casual wear in wet weather conditions

Pros


  • Stylish design
  • Offers a good fit
  • A lightweight design
  • Good for mid-autumn temperatures

Cons


  • Not for work or rough outdoors
  • The rubber outsole lacks traction
  • Pricey

This Wellington from Hunter has a classic look that’ll appeal to those Wellie-fans out there.

At first glance, the design might look a bit plain –  but hold on… there’s more.

This Wellie comes in a range of bright colors with a glossy finish and funky buckle.

Quite simply, Hunter has made this a stylish boot, not a functional one.

If you’re looking for all-round protection from general cold and water, this is the right choice for you.

But, the insulation levels aren’t adequate for freezing weather.

The rubber construction – instead of leather – keeps them light and waterproof.

However, the traction in slippery conditions wasn’t the best with this rubber outsole. It lacks the deep lugs helpful for friction.

In reality, we found the rubber structure durable and comfortable for short walks.

But if you want to move happily over rough ground, look for something with better shock-absorbing features.

Our advice- stick to the city limits. Don’t plan your next outdoor trip with this one.

Beyond that, they are wide around the calves. Another aspect that makes them fit perfectly with thick socks.

At the end of a long day of testing, we chose this Wellie from Hunter as our Editor’s Choice for the best Wellington for women.

Let’s put it this way…

Read Full Review:

If you’re looking for a casual Wellie for moderate ground, this pair from Hunter’s a pretty good pick.

Why Trust Us?

When it comes to testing outdoor products, our TopNotch team never takes shortcuts.

Our goal is to point out the best products for you by checking them out – from all angles.

For that, we test, analyze, connect with long term users and even bug the manufacturer with the strangest queries.

For your real-world review of the Wellington boots, we chose a mixed team.

It consisted of an experienced camper, a casual wearer, and one of our editors with a passion for gardening. And our kids – but they don’t think of it as work.

Best Wellington Boots

In addition to that…

… there was our back office team who shuffled through pages of product specifications and technical details.

With an eye for the smallest detail, we can point out the subtle differences that separated the ten boots.

Finally, we rated each against a carefully chosen set of metrics covering all aspects.

One thing’s for sure…

We don’t make any compromises in our review guidelines.

We make sure to deliver the best information to you at all times.

Skip Buyer’s Guide – Go to Analysis, Comparisons & Ratings

Buyers Guide:

How To Choose The Best Wellington Boots

Best Wellington Boots 01i

If you don’t already know, the Wellington boot made its first appearance in 1817.

It resulted from a collaboration between the Duke of Wellington Arthur Wellesley, and shoemaker George Hoby of London.

Since then, they have thrived through the two World Wars and have become a popular choice for families.

While they’ve been going strong ever since – the range of these boots has expanded immensely.

In addition

… their versatility makes the choice even more difficult.

The traditional gumboot or rain boot can handle practically anything from walking your dog on a rainy day to farming and horse riding.

The point is, with the right set of guidelines, the job of choosing gets easier.

So stick with me here as we list our TopNotch set of guidelines.

What are the Different Types of Wellington Boots?

Wellington boots can be classified based on how you’re going to use them.

Here are the main types.

For regular use: These Wellingtons are for daily use for a dog walk on the streets or for working in your garden. They’re also perfect for kids to play in puddles. Basically, they’re of simple design and lightweight. Also, they tend to be super comfortable for the wearer. They are the right choice if you plan on wearing them for no more than an hour a day.

For work: These Wellington boots are designed for agricultural or industrial use. They’ll keep your feet warm and comfortable for prolonged periods. For that, heavy-duty construction and superior materials are required. This also means the boots can withstand high temperatures and harsh chemicals. Wellingtons boots of this standard are usually made from top-grade rubber or leather and offer excellent grip.

For fashion: Make no mistake about it. Wellingtons also come in a variety of colors and styles to cater to fashion lovers. They present an iconic look in terms of their overall design. These are also good for attending wet and muddy festivals. Also, there are all sorts of funky designs to match the boots with your outfit.

Features To Look Out For

The first thing to look for in a Wellington boot is the functionality. No matter how good they look, a pair of boots should serve your purpose – which will depend on the kind of activity you’re planning on doing.

At the same time, you can also look for versatility. That way, you need not differentiate between “work boots” and “play boots.”

The material of the boots determines not only the durability but also the comfort you can expect.

Wellingtons made from materials like suede or fabric aren’t suitable for rugged outdoor use—the best quality Wellington boots are made from rubber or PVC. You may also prefer a full-grain leather boot as they’re comfortable, breathable, and tough.

Next, you need to choose the type of sole.

While plastic soles are cheaper, they have little tread and can’t absorb vibrations very well.

Frankly, you’ll be risking the health of your joints with these. So rubber soles that offer excellent grip and comfort are a better practical choice. Soles made from patented rubber, like Vibram, are better for slip resistance.

Lastly

… you also need to check the type of lining in your choice of Wellingtons. This is super important if you’re planning to use the boot in cold weather or snow.

The basic types of linings are leather, neoprene, or jersey.

In general, a jersey lining is best for everyday use, and leather offers the best comfort. For top-class insulation in extreme weather, neoprene is the best choice.

Best Wellington Boots 02

Product  & Specifications Explained

Apart from daily use, Wellington boots are also used as safety boots in some workplaces. In the USA, all industrial shoes are guided by the Occupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA) guidelines.

Here are some of the ASTM standards related to safety that you need to know.

  • Puncture/Penetration Resistant (PR) is the shoe’s protection from sharp objects like nails or glass puncturing the outsole and the shoe’s midsole.
  • Another important aspect is the shoe’s protection from electrical shocks and hazards.
  • The Static Dissipative (SD) is a standard for rating how the shoe safely conducts any trace of static electricity into the floor – through the sole.
  • Lastly, there’s a standard that covers the impact of any falling objects on the feet. Crushing loads are covered separately.

Apart from the OSHA standards, you also need to consider other safety aspects depending on your activity. For example, you need to consider a Wellington made with the right level of ankle protection for riding a motorcycle. To prevent hazards from slipping – the correct type of sole is a must.

Best Wellington Boots 08

Things to Consider

Keep in mind that Wellies can come in different heights.

Let’s take a quick look at them.

Knee-high – These give maximum protection. Putting them on and taking off can be a problem. So they’re not usually recommended for casual use.

Full height – These are some of the best Wellies – they rise to the top of your calf. They’re most popular for gardening or walking and will keep you dry.

Half-height – These boots are ideal for those with thick calves as they sit below the calf muscle. They give a good combo of style and protection.

Ankle height – These Wellington boots are a recent development. While they are easy to put on and comfortable, they aren’t suited for rough use.

When you buy a full-height Wellington boot, make sure you get your calf measurement right. The other important thing to consider is the right ankle fit. These two measurements will determine your comfort inside the boot.

Now, getting a high pair of Wellies on and off can be a tough task. So – consider choosing a zipped boot for easy on and off. Another option is to buy a boot removal tool as an accessory.

Jargon Buster

To be honest, there are some technical terms that can get the better of us.

So here are a few terms about boots that you’ll hopefully find useful.

Last – This foot-shaped mold determines the shape of the boot. In general, the last can be of three types – straight, curved, or semi-curved. Interestingly, the last is often termed the “essence” of a shoe. Its design is one of the secrets that brands guard closely.

Insole – This is the part of the boot on which the sock liner rests. In general, a firm insole provides more structural stability for a shoe and is a better option for outdoor footwear.

Midsole – It’s a cushioning layer between the insole and the outsole of a shoe. It’s usually made from EVA, Compression-Molded EVA, or TPU. A midsole can be firm or soft and determines the comfort and overall durability of the boot.

Outsole – This is the bottom part of the shoe that makes contact with the ground and is made from rubber and provides traction. The outsole also determines the “hard” or “soft” feel of any shoe and, as such, defines the overall flexibility.

The Heel Counter – This is the specially designed stiff frame that surrounds the heel of your foot. It not only provides protection but also keeps the heel stable. It’s more important for running shoes as they need superb stability.

TopNotch Top Tip(s)

Last but not least, here are my few special tips for maintaining the best Wellies.

  • After outdoor use, cleaning your pair of Wellies is extremely important. Make sure you don’t put rubber boots in a washing machine or tumble dryer. It’s best to clean the outer surface with hot soapy water. Also, remove the mud from the soles with a soft brush.
  • You can also clean the insides of the boots with a rag soaked in soapy water. But make sure you remove the soap with a clean rag. If the boot smells, use white vinegar and water mixed in equal proportions to clean the insides.
  • A word of caution- Drying rubber boots under direct sunlight can damage them. So it’s best to air dry your Wellington boots. The best way of removing moisture from the insides is by stuffing old newspapers in the shoe.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q What are the best wellies for walking?

The fact is, the best Wellies are those you feel comfortable in. We’ll point you towards our Top Pick, the Danner Crafter boot. It may look like a work boot, but it has all the right features to make your evening walks comfortable. If you’re looking for a budget option, the Guide Gear boot for men can be an excellent pair to pick.

Q.What Wellies does Kate Middleton wear?

Wellies have been a favorite choice of Kate Middleton in various outdoor events and even during official visits. She prefers wearing Le Chameau Vierzonord Neoprene lined boots that are an excellent pair for tackling rough weather. Well, if you’re looking for a chic pair of Wellies, you can’t go wrong with them. However, keep in mind that the royal Weelies come with a high price tag.

Q.Are Hunter’s wellies worth the money?

Hunter’s Willies are one of the best options to keep your feet dry. At the same time, they come in various styles that make them an excellent choice for different activities. The design also makes them travel-friendly. The point is, even though they’re completely waterproof, they aren’t the best choice for tackling extreme cold or snow. Now, whether they are worth the high price tag is something that you’ll need to decide.

Best Wellington Boots 04

Our Analysis, Comparisons & Test Results

Best Wellington Boots 07

So here you are…

… with all the info about choosing a good pair of Wellies right at your fingertips.

A comparative study of this diverse range of Wellies from different brands was no easy task.

But we’ve done all the hard work (the TopNotch team) by testing these Wellies out under each metric.

We used the backyard and the farmhouse of one of our reviewers as our makeshift test-center.

Check out the next section to learn about the comparative analysis of the products under each metric.

Just in case you’re running short of time and want a quick answer – no worries.

The top three Wellies are mentioned at the start as well as the end of this review.

Value for Money

Let’s admit it. We love a product that offers superb quality but doesn’t break the bank. While all the Wellies we chose offer fantastic value, some come with a higher price tag than others, of course.

As usual, we’ve taken into account the price versus performance and graded them accordingly.

So let’s take a look at how our competitors stand against each other.

Best Wellington Boots 03

Value for Your Money Rating

Jileon Rain Boots
9
Men's Carhartt Wellington Boot
8
Danner Men's Boots (Crafter)
8
Guide Gear Men's Mid Bogger Waterproof Rubber Boot
8
Dunlop Boots For Men’s/Women’s
8
Hatley Boys' Printed Rain Boot
8
Polar Women's Winter Rain Boot
8
HUNTER Women's Original Short Rain Boot
7
Georgia Boots Homeland Wellington
6
Georgia Boot Men's (Carbo Tec-M)
6

The Jileon Rain Boots for women came up as the top scorer. It’s a dependable Wellington boot with a spacious design at a reasonable price.

The Men’s Carhartt Wellington Boots comes in second place with an ace combination of style and performance. It isn’t cheap, but the overall quality is TopNotch.

The Danner Crafter Boot secures the third spot with its excellent performance and the right level of attention to the details.

Next, we loved the performance of the Dunlop wet-weather boot. It gets a thumbs up from us for offering excellent waterproof rubber and decent insulation as an inexpensive option.

If you’re looking to buy kids’ boots, the Hatley Boys’ printed rain boots offer good value.

The Hunter women’s boot comes with an iconic design.  But, we couldn’t feel the same about the performance of its outsole and midsole. That makes it unsuitable for serious outdoor work.

Unfortunately, the Georgia Carbo Tec-M ended up with the lowest score in this segment. At this price, we expected it to offer a full range of protective features.

Comfort

Anyone who has used Wellington boots before will understand the need for these to be comfortable. Quite simply, when it comes to a knee-high boot, using it for long hours can be a problem.

The point is, comfort is relative in most cases. So judging it is not an easy task.

At the same time, we considered features like the overall weight, durable lining, and waterproofing.

Best Wellington Boots 06

Comfort Rating

Men's Carhartt Wellington Boot
9
Danner Men's Boots (Crafter)
8
Hatley Boys' Printed Rain Boot
8
Georgia Boot Men's (Carbo Tec-M)
8
Jileon Rain Boot
7
Dunlop Boots For Men’s/Women’s
7
HUNTER Women's Original Short Rain Boot
7
Georgia Boots Homeland Wellington
7
Guide Gear Men's Mid Bogger Waterproof Rubber Boots
6
Polar Women's Winter Rain Boot
6

Also, we considered pulling the Wellies on or off. That can be a pain with some boots.

Actually

… we tested all the Wellies in similar conditions. That made it easy for us to compare the performance of each of the products.

Take a look at how they rank.

The Carhartt Wellington Boot seats at the top spot, followed closely by the Danner Crafter Wellington.

Firstly, none of them are unduly heavy – which would have made them uncomfortable after a few hours of use.

Secondly, the cushioning levels were TopNotch. Both offered the perfect balance of protection from water and comfort.

However, unlike the Danner, the Carhartt Wellington Boot was comfortable right out of the box.

Our Editor’s choice for kids, the Hatley Boys’ Printed rain boot, was another comfortable choice.

The Georgia Carbo Tec-M with its soft leather and Comfort Core insole hits the right marks on the comfort scale.

The Jileon rain boot and the Dunlop boots do not have premium comfort levels. But considering the price tags, they are excellent choices.

The Hunter boot has the right features to make it comfortable for use within city limits.

The Guide Gear waterproof rubber boots were on the heavier side. Some users also noted that putting them on or taking off was an issue.

We noted that the Polar women’s boot was not the best choice for taller women. It is high enough to hit the knees.

Durability/Workmanship

When you’re investing in a Wellington boot, durability is one factor that you can’t ignore. Well, as we all know, durability is linked to the value of the product.

If you think about it…

… durability is often more about the quality and the craftsmanship irrespective of the price.

Best Wellington Boots 05

Durability & Workmanship Rating

Men's Carhartt Wellington Boot
8
Georgia Boot Men's (Carbo Tec-M)
8
HUNTER Women's Original Short Rain Boot
8
Hatley Boys' Printed Rain Boot
8
Danner Men's Boots (Crafter)
7
Guide Gear Men's Mid Bogger Waterproof Rubber Boot
7
Jileon Rain Boots
7
Dunlop Boots For Men’s/Women’s
7
Polar Women's Winter Rain Boot
6
Georgia Boots Homeland Wellington
4

In this list, there were three categories of Wellies. The first category has some premium products that were top-class in terms of durability.

The next group was reasonably priced but still managed to get positive feedback regarding long-term durability.

Also, there were a few Wellies that offered great style and features. But they couldn’t manage high marks under this metric.

To start with, the Carhartt Wellington boots for men hit the top spot again with a superb combination of top-grade leather and textiles. They’re a great choice and will keep your feet well protected.

The Danner Crafter men’s boot is another good pair to buy when you want a well-stitched work boot with electrical hazard protection.

The use of SPR leather in Georgia Carbo Tec-M makes it a solid choice in terms of durability.

This is one category where the Hunter women’s Wellington walking boots performed very well. The top-grade rubber makes it a long-lasting, stylish boot.

The Hatley Boys’ printed rain boot offers excellent durability. Your kids are more likely to outgrow them before they wear out.

Admittedly, the Jileon rain boot and the Dunlop boot aren’t the best Wellies when it comes to durability. But considering the affordable price, they’re great value.

The Georgia homeland Wellington boot stood at the last spot under this metric. The reason being, they had some poor feedback from long-term users.

Waterproof

When you’re working in rough weather conditions, you need Wellies that offer the right support level. These boots need to keep your feet warm and dry.

So for us, the best Wellies need to be completely waterproof.

Best Wellington Boots 09

Waterproof Rating

Danner Men's Boots (Crafter)
9
Jileon Rain Boots
9
Men's Carhartt Wellington Boot
8
Georgia Boot Men's (Carbo Tec-M)
8
HUNTER Women's Original Short Rain Boot
8
Polar Women's Winter Rain Boot
8
Dunlop Boots For Men’s/Women’s
8
Guide Gear Men's Mid Bogger Waterproof Rubber Boot
8
Georgia Boots Homeland Wellington
8
Hatley Boys' Printed Rain Boot
7

Period.

The best part is, almost all the products on our list were outstanding performers under this metric. Many of the options are purely rain boots that are water-resistant but lack an insulated lining.

From high-quality rubber to waterproof linings, the materials used in these Wellies truly make them rain and puddle-proof.

However, a few aren’t tall enough to walk through deep streams or pits. But when you are looking for a good pair of rain boots, they will do the job.

A comparative study under the metric will give you a clear idea.

The Jileon rain boots and the Danner Crafter men’s boot are the chart-toppers under this metric. Besides the great value, they are excellent Wellies to pick when you head out for wet terrain.

The Carhartt Wellington boot comes with a waterproof membrane, which is good- but not as good as the Danner dry liner.

Next, the Hunter boots and the Georgia Carbo Tec-M scored the same marks for keeping our feet dry. The Hunters were also our pick as the best women’s Wellington boots.

If you’re looking for waterproof non-safety walking boots, the Dunlop Wellies are a great choice. The unique compound from Dunlop works its magic through water, mud, and muck.

The Polar rain boot did a great job of keeping water out with the rubber membrane. The quick-dry membrane is another useful feature that helps to keep the insides dry.

The Hatley Boys’ Printed boot was the lowest scorer as it isn’t high enough for deep sections.

Our Final Verdict:
The Best Wellington Boots

Finally…

We’re at the end of our review.

A short break for a cuppa, and I’m back.

So now, you have a complete TopNotch Buyers Guide to help you choose the best pair of Wellies.

We have all ten Wellington boots lined up for you based on their performance.

Honestly, all of our boots have some excellent features.

So the final choice will depend on your exact needs.

Still,  we had to categorize some as winners and others as losers.

So it’s time to stop and check the final results.

Men's Carhartt Wellington Boot
66%
Danner Men's Boots (Crafter)
64%
Jileon Rain Boots
64%
Hatley Boys' Printed Rain Boot
62%
HUNTER Women's Original Short Rain Boot
60%
Dunlop Boots For Men’s/Women’s
60%
Georgia Boot Men's (Carbo Tec-M)
60%
Guide Gear Men's Mid Bogger Waterproof Rubber Boot
58%
Polar Women's Winter Rain Boot
56%
Georgia Boots Homeland Wellington
50%

Conclusion:
The Best Wellington Boots

By now, you’ll have realized that picking the best Wellies is a piece of cake with the right info at hand.

Now you’ve read through this comprehensive TopNotch review, you’ll be better equipped to make the best choice.

Honestly, our team left no stones unturned to deliver you a thorough review of the top Wellies on the market.

A reliable pair of Wellington boots can be your best partner if you’re heading out in wet weather.

While they may look clunky, they’re the best option when it comes to durable, waterproof boots.

In this review, we’ve covered performance, style, protection, and shock-absorbing capabilities.

In the end, we had no option but to go for the Carhartt Wellington boot for men as our Editors’ Choice boot. If you’re looking for the best pair of Wellingtons, this, without a doubt, is it.

We awarded the Danner Crafter boot for men as our TopNotch Top Pick. The perfect balance of comfort and protection makes this the ideal Wellington work boot.

The Jileon rain boot is the TopNotch Best Value Choice. It’s been specially designed as a walking boot as well as a work boot for ladies – two-in-one for added value.

So there you have our picks for the top three Wellies.

And remember!

The Hunter Wellington boot was our Editor’s choice as the best wellie for women. The Hatley Boys’ rain boot is our TopNotch Editor’s Choice as an excellent option for kids.

Now it’s over to you to make your choice!

topnotchoutdoor award

Men's Carhartt Wellington Boots
topnotchoutdoor award

Jileon Rain Boots
topnotchoutdoor award

Danner Men's Boots (Crafter)