Thinking about buying the Columbia Drainmaker XTR? You're in the right place. Ryan and Annie wore it on portages, paddleboards and off-trail legs in Algonquin Provincial Park, side by side with the Salomon Techamphibian 5, OluKai Moku Pae and NRS Paddle Wetshoe.
In this review, you're going to find out how it stacks up on:
- Underfoot Protection & Durability
- Barefoot Comfort
- Wet Traction & Outer Grip
It drained **within three strides of dry land** and gave Ryan no stone-bruising on crushed limestone. It scores 89 out of 100 and ranks #2 in our best kayak shoes guide as our best kayak shoe for all-day paddling.
Let's get into it.
What is the best kayak shoe for all-day paddling?
The best kayak shoe for all-day paddling is the Columbia Drainmaker XTR, which has the plushest midsole of the ten and emptied its water within three strides of dry land.
Columbia Drainmaker XTR
- Midsole: Dual-density foam
- Outsole: Omni-Grip rubber
- Closure: Traditional laces
- Material: Mesh upper
Bottom Line : The plushest ride of the ten, and it empties itself within three strides of dry land.
Pros
- Plush dual-density midsole: no stone-bruising on crushed limestone
- Silky out of the box, no hot spots
- Midsole drain channels empty with a whoosh within three strides
- Omni-Grip held on wet gunwales and damp docks
Cons
- Packs out slightly on slick river muck
- Exposed midsole foam shows abrasions from river rocks
- Owners report pebbles lodging in the drain ports
On Smoke Lake, Ragged Lake and the Oxtongue River
The Columbia is the most cushioned shoe we wore. Substantial dual-density midsole foam gave it the plushest ride of the ten, and Ryan marched over crushed limestone rail beds with no stone-bruising at all. The mesh upper held up well against deadfall.
It was also the easiest to live in. It felt silky on bare skin straight out of the box, with no hot spots, and traditional lacing let us tune the fit across the instep. The big drain channels in the midsole evacuate water with a distinct whoosh within three strides onto dry land.
Grip was very good rather than best. The Omni-Grip rubber has micro-grooves that did well on wet canoe gunwales and damp wood docks, and it handled moderate mud. On slick river muck it packed out a little, which is where the deeper lugs of the Salomon pulled ahead.
Where It Asks Something of You
The exposed midsole foam picked up superficial abrasions from river rocks, so it is not the shoe to drag over granite. On slick river muck the outsole packs out slightly.
Owners report that wading through coarse gravel can lodge small pebbles in the drain ports. We did not see that in our test, but it is worth knowing if your shoreline is gravel.
Spec Sheet vs Our Test
Drain and dry. Columbia says the shoe is built to drain and dry fast. We found that true on dry land: water left through the midsole channels within three strides. In the boat it behaves like a sneaker that happens to be wet, which is why it suits all-day paddling.
Extra lugs with micro-siping. The maker says extra lugs with micro-siping in high-traction areas give superior grip on wet and dry ground. On gunwales and damp docks that is fair. On slick river muck the lugs packed out slightly, so it is very good, not the best, and the Salomon holds better there.
Mesh and webbing upper. Columbia calls the mesh and webbing upper secure and breathable. It was both, and it held against deadfall. The part that wore was the exposed midsole foam, which showed superficial abrasions from river rocks.
Should You Buy the Columbia Drainmaker XTR?
Yes, if you want a shoe that feels like a sneaker and dries while you walk. It tied for the best barefoot comfort of the ten, and for all-day paddling with flat trails to camp it is our pick.
If your route has muddy portages or steep riverbanks, the Salomon has the deeper lugs and the tougher toe. If the water is cold, buy the NRS Paddle Wetshoe instead, because mesh will leave your feet chilled.
Compare With
- Salomon Techamphibian 5: our best overall kayak shoe.
- OluKai Moku Pae: our best kayak shoe for the marina.
- NRS Paddle Wetshoe: our best neoprene kayak shoe for cold water.
- Xero Shoes Aqua X Sport: our best kayak shoe for paddleboarding.
- Speedo Surf Knit Pro: our best slip-on kayak shoe.
- Body Glove 3T Barefoot Cinch: our best split-toe kayak shoe.
- Speedo Surfwalker Pro 3.0: our best kayak shoe for docks and boat launches.
- DLGJPA Quick Drying Water Shoes: our best kayak shoe for beaches.
- ATHMILE Water Shoes: our best packable kayak shoe.
See all 10, and how we tested them, in our best kayak shoes guide.
Editor's Note, 21 November 2026: New review, from the field notes of Ryan and Annie, who wore it in Algonquin Provincial Park, Ontario.
Our Testers
This review was edited by Sean Williams and tested in Algonquin Provincial Park by Ryan Williams and Annie Ward.
- Sean Williams, Editor-in-Chief. A former commercial outdoor copywriter and gear journalist who now runs Top-Notch Outdoor as an independent publisher. He takes no brand-funded trips and runs no supplied ad copy.
- Ryan Williams, Lead Tester. A heavy fleet equipment mechanic and commercial vehicle technician. At 6 ft 2 and 215 lb, he is our heavy, high-impact user.
- Annie Ward, Women’s All-Mountain Snowboard Tester. A freelance graphic designer and committed weekend all-mountain rider.












