Share this article:
TopNotch Outdoor is independent – we research, test, and rate the top products to help you make the right buying choice. We sometimes use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on your purchase. Learn more…
This is the ultimate TopNotch Outdoor Review of the Best Ice Fishing Boots on the market for 2023.
We recently took off for our testing adventure – 3 days on Higgins Lake, Michigan to try out our favorite picks, and we wanna share the experience with you.
We researched the top 17 ice fishing boots, then put them through a series of rigorous field and lab (garage!) tests so you’ll be able to quickly spot the most TopNotch ice fishing boots for your unique needs.
We want to offer you the best choice for your fishing getaways so you can enjoy the outdoors (almost!) as much as we did.
In this guide, we’ll discuss the following:
- Features and benefits you’ll get from our top products;
- Back to back comparison of the best ice fishing boots;
- Our personal experience with the products;
- Lots more…
Whether you want our affordable or premium choice, this comprehensive guide has you covered.
Join me, as we check the top best ice fishing boots in the market for 2023.
- Best Ice Fishing Boots For Extreme Cold Weather
- Best Ice Fishing Boots Between $200 – $250
- Best Budget Ice Fishing Boots
- Best Traction Ice Fishing Boots
- Best Thermal Ice Fishing Boots
- Best Splurge Ice Fishing Boots
- Best Cleats Ice Fishing Boots
- Why Trust Us?
- Buyers Guide:
- How To Choose The Best Ice Fishing Boots
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Our Analysis, Comparisons & Test Results
- 1. Value For Money
- 2. Durability
- 3. Breathability
- 4. Insulation
- 5. Traction
- Our Final Verdict: Best Ice Fishing Boots
- Conclusion: Best Ice Fishing Boots – Perfect For Keeping Your Feet Warm and Dry
Let’s get started
Protecting your feet from extremely cold temperatures and other harmful things that might hurt them is a little bit complicated.
Some consider this as the least priority; however, that’s not the case.
Little did they know that they should keep their feet warm for them to stay longer in the cold to catch fish.
You see, the warmer your feet are, the more hours you stay, and the more fish you’ll catch for today!
And compromising your feet is not a good idea as well.
Looking at the best ice fishing boots for your fishing is an investment, especially when these pairs will last you for seasons.
Didn’t I mention it?
Searching out through the net is a whole lotta work, too, as it’s bombarded with different products that you can choose from.
And this is kinda confusing, most especially for beginners.
There are also different features that you might and might not need.
Sounds a bit confusing, right?
To give you the most accurate review…
We tested these 7 ice fishing boots based on our metrics: value for money and qualities like durability, breathability, insulation, and traction.
Wanna know more?
Let’s get walking…
Best Ice Fishing Boots For Extreme Cold Weather
1 – Sorel Men’s Bear Extreme Snow Boot
- Removable inner boot can be worn separately
- Omni-Heat technology for heat management and retention
- Water- and wind-resistant
- Comfortable even with extended wear
- Impressive grip
- Removable liners come off when you take off the boots
- Difficulty getting on for those with a high instep or large calves
As the name suggests, the Sorel Bear Extreme Snow Boot shall take you to a fishtastic victory.
It’s made to last in extreme weather conditions to help your feet get absolutely warm and comfortable.
For the upper, it uses a water- and wind-resistant PU-coated synthetic textile.
The insole has a removable 9mm recycled felt with Omni-Heat reflective lining too.
Wanna know the best part?
Sorel’s patented Omni-Heat technology is an innovative way to retain heat. It allows comfort in temperatures as low as -60 degrees Fahrenheit.
The midsole has a 2.5 mm bonded felt frost plug, with a sealed 6mm ThermoPlus felt for added warmth.
A high-quality vulcanized rubber bottom shell composes the outsole. This ensures stability even on slippery surfaces. Plus, it features AeroTracs, a particular non-loading lug that increases grip.
I recently tested this when I went through Arethusa Falls. The place was freezing and full of ice, and I gotta say that this boot works wonders!
Despite the numbing situation, it kept my feet warm and flexible.
But wait, there’s more.
The heel is about 1.25 inches tall, and the platform is 3.25-inch wide to provide comfort all day long.
Another feature is the drawstring and barrel lock system for easy adjustment and boot removal.
But wait, here’s the thing…
It’s a bit heavy because of its materials, so expect to walk a little bit slower than usual.
However, despite all its great features combined, how can you not survive the cold?
Best Ice Fishing Boots Between $200 – $250
2 – Baffin Men’s Snow Monster Insulated Boot
- Exceptional grip and traction with IcePaw technology
- Thermaplush provides heat retention and vapor release
- Soft insole molds according to your foot shape
- Comfortable even with extended wear
- Durable even in the harshest weather conditions
- Narrow design requires going up a few sizes
- Bulky especially when driving
If you’re looking for a pair of boots that’s really worth the price, then Baffin Snow Boots is the one that you should score.
The Baffin Snow Monster Boot impressed us with itshybrid style boot for high-performance.
These cold weather boots use insulated leather and a waterproof upper with Thermaplush technology that’ll make you feel smooth and soft.
This material composes the Snow Monster Boots’ innermost layer, which will keep your feet warm, provide a better fit, and best of all, a superior comfort compared to others.
The waffle-comb footbed uses advanced thermo-set polymers.
And the good news?
It was then manufactured together with the midsole in one continuous process. This creates the perfect balance of protection, low weight, and grip.
Perfect for fishing!
In terms of protection, Baffin’s cold weather boots have an integrated ArcticFlex feature.
Plus, the rubber bottom sole features a durable IcePaw technology that provides better traction during wet and slippery days.
Although a bit bulky, this will definitely protect your feet all throughout your stay outdoors.
So, suppose you can compromise the bulkiness of this product and prioritize your protection as we did. In that case, this doesn’t have to be a problem.
To tie this up, the boots have a bungee-cord speed lacing system with an adjustable cuff. This saves your time in choosing the snug you prefer.
Best Budget Ice Fishing Boots
3 – Kamik Men’s Greenbay 4 Winter Boot
- Flexible material makes it easy to walk
- Superior traction with RubberHE technology
- Easy on/off with large shaft (extra benefit for those with wide feet)
- Moisture-wicking lining for a quick dry
- Sturdy yet lightweight for maximum comfort
- Insole lacks cushion
- Metal buckle is flimsy
If you want dependable boots, you’ll be glad to know that Kamik has been around for 120 years.
To start with…
It’s one of the most affordable boots we’ve bought and tested. The price doesn’t reflect the features at all. Actually, it’s more than what we expected for its price.
The Kamik Greenbay 4 Winter Boot features a lightweight and waterproof 600 denier Nylon shell.
What’s more jaw-dropping is that it has a removable 8mm Thermal Guard liner made with 100% recycled content.
Yes.. you read it right. 100% recycled content. Cool right?
When it comes to warmth, its lace-lock snow collar makes sure your potentially wet feet stay warm and dry.
However, don’t expect much when it comes to comfortability as its insoles don’t have a cushion with it.
These can keep you warm in temperatures up to -40 degrees Fahrenheit.
We also appreciated its Adjustable Velcro Strap which makes sure that you don’t slip or fall.
Just to quickly share, we had this cold encounter outdoors where the ice went so slippery. Luckily, this saved us from getting hurt.
What makes the rubber sole special is the technology.
Called RubberHe, the lightweight and waterproof material offers superior grip and flexibility.
It’s also 50% lighter than natural rubber and 100% recyclable.
Made in the USA, these boots are high-quality and environmental-friendly.
Best Traction Ice Fishing Boots
4 – Muck Boot Arctic Sport Men’s Winter Boot
- Easy to wear and remove with pull-tab
- Shock-absorbent EVA midsole for comfort and cushion
- Outstanding warmth retention
- High-quality materials
- Lightweight addition to your standard outdoor gear
- Not slip-resistant on solid surfaces (e.g. wet tiles)
- Not ideal for those with short height/legs
The Muck Boot Arctic Sport Men’s Winter Boot is a comfortable weather boot for outdoor activities in ice-cold temperatures.
Wanna know why?
These boots have molded lugs with a fully-sealed rubber shell that extends up to the ankle.
With a total height of 13.27 inches, it will keep you warm and dry even if you’re buried ankle-deep in ice.
Check out its stretch-fit top-line binding feature that hugs your legs to keep the cold air out and keep the warmth in.
It’s suitable even for those with wide calves. (like me) Plus, it can withstand temperatures as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit.
The Muck Boots Arctic Sport has a warm fleece lining under the footbed with a 2mm thermal foam underlay.
There’s a lightweight EVA midsole for extra comfort too!
It also has 5mm neoprene sheets—these help absorb shock, maintain heat, and prevent chafing.
In cases of heavy ice, slush, or hail, there’s a grippy rubber sole to provide double reinforcement on the instep which kept us planted.
Plus, they’re 100% waterproof.
They had the best traction on our list.
Best Thermal Ice Fishing Boots
5 – Muck Boot Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boot
- Outstanding warmth retention
- No need to break in with easy stretch Nylon
- Easy to clean and maintain
- Flexible and lightweight
- Breathable air mesh lining
- A bit difficult to drive in
- Lack of heel kick makes it difficult to remove
If your primary concern is warmth, the Muck Boot Arctic Pro Hunting Boot will be your winter companion.
You know what?
Among Muck Boots, these boots are the warmest. They’re also 100% waterproof.
Worry no more about the pain in your ankle and soles ’cause these boots feature a soft and durable fleece lining to ideally ensure your comfort.
Not only that…
It has an extra-thick 2mm thermal foam underlay to boost warmth. Overall, this is a genuine cold-weather boot with a comfort range of -60 to 30 degrees Fahrenheit.
Besides providing comfort and flexibility,
The 8mm neoprene material is water- and shockproof. Shocking right?
As you wear them, the boots will adjust to your foot shape to prevent blisters and chafing.
Now, that is an essential factor, most especially for anglers that stay over extended time outside.
These boots have a stretch-fit top-line. This will comfortably snug to your calf to ensure you’re safe from the cold and debris. There’s double reinforcement in the instep, heel, and Achilles area.
Besides warmth, these boots also take into consideration your safety.
The Bob-Tracker outsole is durable and rugged for performance in harsh weather conditions. It also uses high-grade rubber to provide extra toughness.
It’s the best thermal boots on the list!
Best Splurge Ice Fishing Boots
6 – Sorel Men’s Conquest Snow Winter Boot
- Comfortable even with extended wear
- Versatile; can be used for everyday use or for winter activities
- 100% Waterproof with adjustable drawstrings
- Rubber outsole provides a stable grip
- Durable even in the harshest conditions
- Rubber may separate from leather and crack over time
- Some reports of stitching issues
The Sorel Men’s Conquest Snow Winter Boots is when function meets fashion.
What amazed me the most is its versatility! These boots aren’t only suitable for ice fishing. It can go well for active winter sports, such as sledding, or hunting.
On the other hand…
These boots use waterproof full-grain leather and synthetic textile upper. The sealed seams ensure that your feet will stay warm and dry.
It features 400g of Thinsulate Ultra Insulation.
Thinsulate is a type of insulation that will keep you warm in extreme cold. What’s more incredible is there’s also a built-in gaiter and barrel lock closure for extra protection.
This cold-weather boot has an Achilles strap with a shatter-resistant buckle closure to give you a locked-in feel.
I’m telling you, it’s one of the best that we tested.
When walking on uneven terrain, you can tighten the straps for your ankles to have extra support.
The molded EVA comfort footbed is removable too. This reduces weight and adds thermal protection if you’re staying in the cold for extended hours.
The rugged outsole is an injection molded thermal rubber shell.
This wraps around the boots for extra protection and warmth. That’s pretty bomb!
Just be extra careful when using this pair, as I’ve experienced stitching issues in the soles.
Best Cleats Ice Fishing Boots
7 – Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boot
- Exceptional insulation even with extended wear
- Non-slip rubber sole even in slippery conditions
- Snug but flexible fit
- Sturdy body to prevent water intrusion
- High-quality, durable materials
- Bulky especially when driving
- Heavier than other boots
The Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boot will be your ice fishing companion for years to come.
What about that?
Well, my friend, these boots use 100% full-grain insulated leather and a waterproof seam-sealed upper.
It also features a removable boot liner and a multi-layer inner boot system, thanks to Baffin’s Thermaplush technology.
Plus, there’s a top cinch to keep you extra toasty.
The waffle-comb insole is a flexible, squishy surface. This molds to the shape of your foot to offer added comfort as time goes by.
But take note
It’s a bit heavy unlike other boots in the market. Well, that’s because of its materials.
Also, I do not recommend wearing this when you drive because it’s a bit bulky. Bring extra shoes for your driving and wear this when you’re already outside.
The base features an Arctic rubber shell, EVA midsole, and polar rubber outsole. When combined, these become durable rubber boots that provide full traction and non-slip grip!
The last thing you need when ice fishing is to keep checking your boots.
In that case, the Multi D-Ring lace fastening will solve your problem. It will keep the laces intact and together so you can focus on more important things.
Why Trust Us?
One thing is for sure.
My long-term outdoor buddies and I want to give you the best comprehensive guide that you can use for your future outdoor adventure with your friends and family.
With our personal experience and research combined, we believe that it’s our responsibility to share with you what we know and what we learned outdoors.
Who might know? We may be outdoor buddies soon too!
Not only that…
…We already know the hassle of diving into the market and internet searching for the best equipment to use outdoors.
And choosing the real ones that are perfect for the type of adventurer you are is quite tricky.
So, our objective is simple.
And that is to give you unbiased reviews so you can choose which ones are perfect for you!
You see, we had great adventures in ice fishing in different places.
Not only that, we experienced real-time difficulties and fun moments together too.
And after all those challenging core adventures we had, here we are now curating and sorting out the best boots we’ve tried and tested.
So what are you waiting for?
Choose your best ice fishing boots now.
How To Choose The Best Ice Fishing Boots
Features to look out for
Just like what we always say… always check the lookout for the essential features that will fit your everyday needs.
Looking at what type of adventurer you are is a must too!
You see, too many features that you won’t need is really unnecessary
So, for you to take away the hassle, we sorted out these necessary features that you should look out for when purchasing the right weather boot!
1. Warmth and Comfortability
The main reason to buy this equipment is for you to avoid cold feet while you’re outside. So, choose this as one of the priority features that you should look out for.
Will it give me my desired warmth and comfortability? How long does this pair of ice fishing boots keep me warm?
Ask these to yourselves, and surely you’ll get an answer.
Traction is necessary for you not to slip on slippery ice during the winter (unless you wanna experience what we had)
This is one of the necessary features because your protection is at risk when you purchase boots that don’t have the best quality when it comes to traction.
Always remember… Safety comes first.
3. Size and breathability
I bet you won’t enjoy wearing these boots if this doesn’t fit you at all.
You know why?
‘Cause even if you have warmth and protection, there’s no balance just because your boots don’t fit your feet.
All will be useless when you become irritable because your feet feel like dying.
So, another tip, my friend.
Think again and consider this feature.
Man, what’s more good about purchasing equipment that will last you a long time? Not only will it be your best buddy outdoors, but this also saves a lot of money!
Choose and purchase wisely.
Check out products with outstanding and durable materials like neoprene and other synthetic ones because these are just some of the materials that can help your boots last longer.
These are things to consider
This is a no-brainer. Of course, consider your budget!
Can I afford these?
Asking this question to yourself doesn’t mean that you have to compromise features just to get an affordable one.
And that’s why we’re here.
Don’t worry cause we sorted out the 7 best boots that we’re sure to fit in your budget. Want the expensive one? We got you! Want the best budget but with great features? We still got you!
2. The type of ice fishing enthusiast/ adventurer you are
Before you check out features, check and evaluate yourself first.
Am I a hardcore fisherman? Do I prefer to stay longer hours outside just to fish? Do I often play with cold water but still don’t want my feet to get wet?
These questions will help you evaluate yourself.
After this, you are now ready to go search and look for the best ice fishing boots that’ll suit your needs.
3. Weight of the booties
If you’re a real fisherman and a long-term user of boots, you know the struggle.
Ice boots are often heavy and bulky because of their protective materials.
Always check if you can handle the weight or not. Not considering this might turn you into a 70- year old man complaining that his back hurt when you got home.
As you go through our buying guide, you might encounter these jargon words that we can’t really omit because it is what they really are.
We’re taking out the confusion in you as we give you the meanings of each below.
- Neoprene: It is a synthetic fabric usually used to make waterproof equipment like rash guards. Besides giving water resistance, it also keeps your feet protected and warm when you wear boots that are made of neoprene.
- Traction: In this review, it measures how the boots can give you a non-slippery feature. The higher the traction score, the better.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. What are the warmest ice fishing boots?
The warmest boots are those boots that are made out of Neoprene and Fleece.
You obviously heard neoprene and fleece lining on this buyer’s guide. Yes, they are excellent materials for boots that can keep your feet warm and comfortable.
Neoprene is a synthetic rubber material that protects your feet from cold weather conditions. At the same time, the soft fleece lining can be lightweight and produces a thermal feeling since this provides moisture in your feet’ soles.
So, suppose your feet are a little bit sensitive as usual, you should definitely look for boots that offer this kind of material.
Q. What are the key criteria for buying ice fishing boots?
Looking for the perfect pair of boots for your fishing escapade is necessary.
So, to experience less hassle, we curated some of the key criterias that you have to consider when you want to invest in a pair of boots that will last you for a long time.
Check them out below:
1. Warmth and Comfort
It’s not only your hands that need to be numb- free and protected. But your feet as well.
Imagine not being able to walk correctly because you can’t feel your feet anymore because of the winter weather?
We don’t want that, and we know you don’t want to.
Consider checking out how your preferred booths can provide you the best comfort and warmth while you fish. Check out the materials that we provided in the previous section, and you’re sure to go!
2. The boot’s weight
Check whether you’re able to carry the boots within your feet. If it’s too heavy for you, then don’t even buy it.
This is important, but most anglers neglect this criterion.
But in my opinion, you should consider this one
You know why?
The after-effect of having to wear heavy boots for a long time is entirely terrible.
It hurts a lot… and neither of us wants to experience back pains and the like.
Most ice fishing boots on the market come with expensive price tags that are not really worth shelling out for.
To be honest, I’ve tried buying very expensive winter boots, but they just weren’t up my alley – for a number of reasons.
And that’s when I learned not to base features on the tag. Just look for features that suit you and make sure that it’s worth the purchase!
Q. Do I need to buy ice cleats in addition to specialized ice fishing boots?
The main point of using fishing gloves is to keep your hands warm during the long hours that you’re outside. This also prevents you from getting cuts and wounds from other gadgets and materials you use while fishing.
Well, I can say that it’s not necessary. We tried specialized winter boots during the winter weather and it’s safe and reliable.
It’s still up to your choice. If you want more extra protection, then you can purchase one. However, it’ll cost you another penny if that’s the case.
Our Analysis, Comparisons & Test Results
1. Value For Money
Value for money might sound simple, but it’s not. Have you ever felt pure contentment on your purchase because of its overflowing features that are worth the tag?
Luckily, Baffin Men might make you feel this way as it ranked first among all those products that are on the list.
It may be a bit pricey but rest assured that you get what you paid for.
It has an exceptional grip, plus it gives you the best warmth during winter making your feet sole comfortable and numb-free.
It has all the essential and necessary features you need in a pair of winter boot with its price.
If you want an alternative, you can grab a pair of Sorel Men’s Boots too! It offers the same quality and features as Baffin.
Although other ice fisging boots on this list give the same features, Baffin Men Snow Monster stood out for its quality.
No wonder it was chosen to be the best value for money!
It’s better safe than sorry. Highly durable purchasing boots definitely brings you significant advantages.
First, it’ll last you for seasons, and second, it will save you a lot of money.
Thanks to Baffin Men’s Control Max for being the best durable ice weather boots on the market.
Wanna know why?
I’ll show you why
Well, it has an Arctic rubber shell, EVA midsole, and polar rubber outsole. When combined, these features provide this pair a full traction and non-slip drip.
Not only that… This results in these boots becoming durable rubber boots as well.
Kamik Men’s boots got the last rank, but we’re sure that this offers more advanced features other than being durable.
Personally, I’m a fan of ice boots that offers a great feature when it comes to breathability.
Not only does it help my feet feel the air. It also helps me not get the irritable feeling that it’s a little bit too much inside.
It’s like, neither do I want cold feet nor too little space inside, which makes me feel too hot and suffocated.
You feel me? I bet you do!
It’s good news that all of these products performed well!
However, Sorel Men’s, Baffin Men’s, and the Muck Boot series made it to the top, as we graded them a solid 9 out of 10.
When we say solid, it literally is!
…Sorel Boots features Omni Heat technology that gave us a warm and, at the same time, comfortable feeling.
Really perfect if you want your feet not to feel too much pressure while standing outdoors.
Although every pair performed well…
…Baffin Men’s control max boots were placed at the last position not because they didn’t do well. It’s just that the other products really gave more freedom and a suffocating environment for the feet.
To make sure your feet stay warm during your fishing adventures, make sure that your ice fishing boot has an excellent insulating material that will help trap the heat inside.
To be honest, there are various synthetic insulations designed to keep you warm, and finding the right one for you is challenging.
Well, we sorted out other steps for you and created this chart where you can choose from.
Yes, as you can see, they have pretty high scores because they all did well!
…The 2 pairs of booties that excelled are Sorel Men’s and Muck Boot Arctic Pro.
Suppose you check the summary of these in the previous sections of this buyer’s guide. In that case, you’ll notice that they have an exceptional feature when it comes to insulation.
Both have an additional extra-thick 2mm thermal foam that adds warmth to your feet, especially in the cold weather.
Not only that…
…Both are 100% waterproof too! Worry no more about getting your feet cold, wet, and cranky.
Now we’re down to the last metric that we set for all these pairs of booties for your ice fishing needs.
So far, we’re happy that all the boots performed well!
…A pair of ice boots with good traction is necessary when you’re about to go ice fishing.
You don’t wanna get back home with new wounds and sprain, right?
So you should be careful not to slip on ice.
Sadly, you can’t just do it on your own balance. You need help with your boots. So purchasing a pair with great traction is an excellent idea.
…Muck Boot Arctic Sport Boots got you covered!
We rated this one a solid 10 out of 10!
It has a grippy rubber sole to provide double reinforcement on the instep to keep you planted in every step you take.
…Sorel Men’s Bear Extreme can’t provide the traction that our top 1 can give. So, I wouldn’t recommend this in extreme weather conditions ‘cause it might not take the snow below your feet.
Our Final Verdict: Best Ice Fishing Boots
Finally on the Final Verdict!
Here, you can see which pairs of ice fishing boots stood out and performed TopNotch!
After this, the next thing you should do is to get your mind ready on what pair to buy
Here they are, check them out!
Conclusion: Best Ice Fishing Boots – Perfect For Keeping Your Feet Warm and Dry
We’ve reached the end of our Best Ice Fishing Boots review and we hope our article has helped you find the best ice fishing boots for your next trip.
If you’d like our two cents worth, our Editor’s choice of the best ice fishing boots is the Sorel Men’s Bear Extreme Snow Boot. It features a patented Omni-Heat technology that’ll keep your feet warm in the coldest weather. They have excellent grip while ensuring your TopNotch comfort – even during extended use – you’ll be delighted to hear.
The Baffin Men’s Snow Monster Insulated Boot is also another great choice. It’s made of leather, so you know it’ll last you years. The ergonomic insoles kept our feet plenty cozy. Plus, the outsole provided non-slip traction – just what you need.
If you’re concerned with budget, the Kamik Men’s Greenbay 4 Winter Boots have great features without the hefty price tag. They’re made of lightweight 600 denier Nylon. They also have RubberHe, a waterproof outsole that was flexible during our tests and gave excellent grip.
Ice fishing is an absorbing winter activity. But always put your safety and comfort above everything else. Finding a good pair of boots is key to make your ice fishing trip long, happy and memorable.