Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves Review

Our Verdict: Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves

A tough work glove with a waterproof insert, best for rough handling and dry-hand chores on the ice.

A rugged Carhartt work glove with a Dri-Max waterproof insert and an insulated microfiber lining, built to take abuse.

So, is it any good?

A well-known brand at a reasonable price, and it survives rough work.

The polytex shell with a reinforced palm outlasts thin fishing gloves.

These shrugged off drilling and hauling gear all day, but after an hour sitting still my fingers started to lose heat.

Shaun, Top-Notch field tester

Reasons to buy:

• Tough, abrasion-resistant shell
• Dedicated waterproof insert
• Grippy reinforced palm
• Snow-blocking fleece cuff

Reasons to avoid:

• No bare-finger access
• Insert can stay damp after heavy use
• Warmth fades on long static sits

Our Analysis, Comparisons, and Test Results

The Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves scored 82 out of 100 overall.

It is strongest on value for money and weakest on flexibility & dexterity.

Here is how it did on every metric we tested, with exactly how each score compares to the rest of the field.

Value for Money

A well-known brand at a reasonable price, and it survives rough work.

The polytex shell with a reinforced palm outlasts thin fishing gloves.

Owners rate it good value for shoveling and general winter chores.

Value for Money	Rating
Best in test	10/10
Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves	9/10
Category average	8.4/10
Worst in test	6/10

Warmth & Comfort

A Dri-Max waterproof insert paired with a microfiber insulated lining warms the hand.

Owners say it keeps hands warm for about an hour, less for long static sits.

Here's what that means:

A fleece cuff and wrist strap keep snow and slush out.

Warmth & Comfort	Rating
Best in test	10/10
Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves	7/10
Category average	6.9/10
Worst in test	4/10

Water Resistance

A dedicated waterproof insert makes it one of the more water-blocking gloves here.

Some owners report the inside stays wet after heavy snow shoveling, so the insert is not perfect.

Stronger than the fabric fishing gloves, but not a sealed neoprene glove.

Good for wet snow, weaker for prolonged soaking.

Water Resistance	Rating
Best in test	10/10
Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves	9/10
Category average	6.4/10
Worst in test	5/10

Flexibility & Dexterity

A full-finger work glove with no bare-finger access, so knot tying means taking it off.

Grippy reinforced palm handles tools and rods well.

More dexterous than a heated mitten, less than a slit-finger glove.

Flexibility & Dexterity	Rating
Best in test	10/10
Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves	7/10
Category average	7.7/10
Worst in test	5/10

Versatility

Really a winter work and chore glove that doubles for ice fishing.

Best where you handle gear and augers rather than tie fine knots.

Adjustable wrist strap suits varied layers and cuffs.

Versatility	Rating
Best in test	10/10
Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves	8/10
Category average	7.8/10
Worst in test	6/10

Should You Buy the Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves?

A tough work glove with a waterproof insert, best for rough handling and dry-hand chores on the ice.

It is best suited to anglers who value durability and rough-handling grip over fine dexterity.

Bottom line?

The big win: Tough, abrasion-resistant shell.

The main compromise: No bare-finger access.

We scored it 82 out of 100.

What Other Ice Fishing Gloves Should You Consider?

Not sold on this one? A few others from our testing are worth a look.

The Glacier Glove Ice Bay Gloves is our best waterproof ice fishing gloves. The one glove here that is genuinely waterproof, so pick it when your hands go in the water.

The HANDLANDY 3M Thinsulate Winter Gloves is our best budget warm winter gloves. A cheap, warm ski-style glove for anglers who want insulation on a budget and do not need bare fingers.

The KastKing PolarBlast Convertible Mittens is our best convertible mittens for cold. A warmer four-layer convertible mitten for anglers who want more insulation than the Palmyth flip.

Specifications

Style	Insulated work glove
Shell	Polytex with reinforced palm
Waterproofing	Dri-Max insert
Lining	Microfiber insulated
Cuff	Fleece with wrist strap
Water rating	Waterproof insert, not sealed
Use	Winter work and fishing

Conclusion: Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves

After testing it against the other top ice fishing gloves, the Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves earns its place as our best durable waterproof gloves pick.

Its standout strength: Tough, abrasion-resistant shell.

Still deciding?

The main thing to weigh before you buy: No bare-finger access.

If you want anglers who value durability and rough-handling grip over fine dexterity, it belongs at the top of your shortlist.

Still comparing? See exactly where the Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Gloves ranks against the full field in our 10 Best Ice Fishing Gloves guide.

Check Latest Prices See Customer Reviews & Feedback